A Comparison of Command Economies and Market Economies

CHARACTERISTIC

COMMAND ECONOMY

MARKET ECONOMY

ownership of resources:

government ownership

private ownership

decision making:

centrally planned

by the market

motivation:

"social good" = INCENTIVE PROBLEM

self interest and profit = INCENTIVE

prices and wages:

set by the government
often distorted causing
COORDINATION PROBLEM

set by the market
change with market
help coordinate resources
help achieve alloc. and prod. eff.

result:

inefficiency
full employment
low inflation
low standard of living
shortages
more equal distribution of income

alloc. and prod. efficiency
periods of unemploy.
periods of inflation
high standard of living
wide range available
less equal distribution of income

problems:

lack of incentives = INCENTIVE PROBLEM
distorted prices = COORDINATION PROBLEM

inefficiency
corruption=self interest

IF lack of competition = inefficiency
inequality
changing prices
instability (UE, IN)
pollution

OVERALL:

LESS FOR MORE = INEFFICIENT

  • Allocative INefficiency
  • Productive INefficiency
  • LESS Economic Growth
  • Maybe more Equity
  • Usually Full employment

MORE FOR LESS = EFFICIENT

  • Allocative Efficiency
  • Productive Efficiency
  • MORE Economic Growth
  • Maybe more INequity
  • Periods of UNemployment